While it is common knowledge that Ticketmaster has made buying concert tickets one of the most frustrating processes this side of TSA taking over airport security (see my April 14 post), the City of Baltimore has brought up a new reason why their service fees are unacceptable.
Filed in the Northern Division of U.S. District Court in Maryland, Live Nation is now facing a class action lawsuit in Baltimore. This lawsuit takes a new approach as it accuses Live Nation’s Ticketmaster division of being a scalper by charging above face value for tickets, which is against the law in the City of Baltimore.
What a genius move on Baltimore’s part! Accusing Ticketmaster of being just like the sketchy guy who stands on the street corner in front of a venue with a cardboard sign is brilliant!
The lawsuit states that Ticketmaster “consistently and regularly sell tickets to events in Baltimore City at prices far exceeding the face value of those tickets” and that it “imposes and conspires to impose charges in addition to the face value of tickets denominated as ‘service charges,’ ‘convenience fees,’ ‘processing fees’ and other unlawful charges.”
It goes on to state that “because the Defendants sell tickets to Baltimore City events, they are acting as ‘ticket agencies’ under Baltimore City law – but none of the Defendants are licensed, as required, with Baltimore City.”
You tell ‘em Baltimore!
Here’s some more good stuff: “Even if the Defendants had been licensed ‘ticket agencies’…their activities described herein still would constitute wholesale violations of Baltimore City scalping laws. These laws, designed to protect the public, are simply ignored by the Defendants, who dominate the ticket sales market for events in Baltimore City.”
The lawsuit was filed by Baltimore resident Andre Bourgeois, who bought tickets in 2009 to see Jackson Browne. The tickets had a face value of $52 each but then Ticketmaster “allegedly” tacked on additional services charges of $12 per ticket, making the ticket price skyrocket 20 percent.
According to the lawsuit, since the city prohibits ticket agencies from adding convenience charges that are over $0.50 above face value, Ticketmaster broke the law as it routinely adds fees way over the allowed amount.
“The Defendants…have completely ignored the restrictions of Baltimore City law and have criminally overcharged their customers,” the lawsuit states. “They have reaped huge financial windfalls from operating outside of the rules which apply to them.”
The lawsuit is accusing Ticketmaster of the following: Money Had and Received, Negligent Misrepresentation, violation of the Maryland Consumer Protection Act, Deceit by Non- Disclosure or Concealment and violation of the federal Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO).
I’m impressed with the persistence of both Mr. Bourgeois and the City of Baltimore. They are not taking what Ticketmaster does lightly and are serious about making them pay. And they should because Ticketmaster steals from the people (the music-loving public) who make them rich and it’s ridiculous. Based on 2009 public finance reports, Ticketmaster generated over $1 billion in revenues as a result of the fees, which were charged on tickets worth a total of $8 billion.
“Defendants represented to Mr. Bourgeois that the additional service charges imposed on him were legitimate and collectible,” the lawsuit states. “Defendants did not disclose to Mr. Bourgeois that they were not licensed as ticket agencies by the Baltimore City Director of Finance. Defendants also did not disclose to Mr. Bourgeois that Defendants were prohibited by the Baltimore City Code from imposing and collecting the additional service charges which he paid.”
The lawsuit continues, “Despite full knowledge that Mr. Bourgeois and other Class members could not be legally charged for additional service charges, the Defendants willfully and knowingly charged Plaintiff and other members of the Class service charges in excess of the face value of each ticket they sold, as well as in excess of the $0.50 permissible service charges for licensed ticket agencies. Defendants pocketed these illegal service charges and refused to credit any portion of them to the ticket purchases of Plaintiff and members of the Class.”
Game on Ticketmaster. What’s your next move?
I can’t wait to see the outcome of this one! About time someone did something too – $12 per ticket in extra charges is insane!
I hope this lawsuit makes a difference. My concert-going schedule has diminished as a result of the extra fees and that really makes me mad. There are so many people out there who aren’t experiencing the live music they should because of Ticketmaster and something has to be done.
Mike Hardaker says
But wait aren’t Stubhub and Ticketmaster affiliated? For more music gossip check Colorado News. Great job on the site Laura!!
Thanks Mike – nice plug for your site as well 🙂